5 Best Cakes in Indianapolis🥇

5 Best Cakes in Indianapolis

Below is a list of the best and premier cakes in Indianapolis. To help you find the best cakes near you in Indianapolis, we’ve created our own list based on this review score list.

Indianapolis’ best cakes:

The top rated cakes in Indianapolis are:

  • Smallcakes Cupcakery & Creamery – bake and frost 18 flavors every morning
  • BitterSweet – is a neighborhood bakery that offers homemade baked goods
  • The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers – has had a passion for baking and cooking all her life
  • Princess Confections Bakery – also offer cake decorating workshops
  • Brenda’s Cakes – especially specialized in custom cakes and catering for all events

Smallcakes Cupcakery & CreamerySmallcakes Cupcakery & Creamery

Smallcakes Cupcakery & Creamery Bake and frost 18 signatory flavors every morning, fresh from scratch. The ice cream flavors are a slumber for the well-known cupcake recipes from Smallcakes. They take the great flavors of their cupcakes and turn them into incredible, rich and creamy ice cream. He founded the hectically famous Smallcakes Cupcakery, which bakes and freezes 18 signature flavors every morning, fresh from the batter. Smallcakes attribute seasonal and special flavors to Jeff.


Cupcakes, ice cream, dine-in, delivery


Address: 930 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 389-5447
Website: www.smallcakescupcakery.com


“Amazingly tasty and filling cupcakes! The flavors are so good that I couldn’t pick just one! They even have special flavors that only come up every now and then, like an orange cream and pop cake! Really great to find and will definitely be back! “- Lyle B.


Bittersweet is a bakery in the neighborhood that offers homemade baked goods made from high-quality ingredients. They sell sliced ​​cakes and a variety of 4-6 flavors a day. Cake, lemon bars, brownies, pecan bars, cheesecake, coffee cake and giant cinnamon rolls on the weekend. They are located at 5545 East Washington Street in Indianapolis, Indiana. Tailor-made whole cakes and desserts by appointment from Monday to Sunday.


Classic cakes, pies, tarts, specialty cakes, desserts


Address: 5545 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317) 602-8665
Website: www.bittersweetindy.com


“Bought the German Chocolate Cake and didn’t disappoint! Everyone in the family loved it! I will definitely return for all of my future cakes and treats. “- Martha B.

Gwendolyn Rogers’ cake bakeryGwendolyn Rogers' cake bakery

Gwendolyn Rogers’ cake bakery has been passionate about baking and cooking all her life. Gwendolyn’s Cake Bake stores have become Indiana’s destination to celebrate birthdays, anniversaries, and all the special occasions that life has to offer. Gwendolyn has been baking since she was six and has baked hundreds of cakes for weddings and baked them for many famous people over the past 49 years. Gwendolyn and its business have received numerous awards and recognitions for quality.


Cakes, pies, desserts, breakfast, reservations, gift shop, private events


Address: 6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 257-2253
Website: www.thecakebakeshop.com


“Whimsical and Magical Place! No wonder why it’s one of Oprah’s favorite spots. We were lucky enough to find a spot at the bar to sit and eat when we were walkable. I strongly recommend making reservations weeks in advance if you are planning a stopover here. The mission is to create a magical experience for guests, and they definitely do, especially in the small, beautiful details. The decor changes and the menu is fresh. When my husband’s lemonade came out with glitter on the lemon garnish, all I knew was it was the best place! Even though we’re not locals we’ve been back since because it’s just so amazing! “- Tara A.

Princess Confections BakeryPrincess Confections Bakery

Princess Confections Bakery would be excellent to express your style through the beautiful custom wedding cake of your dreams. Cakes are Alana’s preference and where her art is best. Faux and partial faux cakes are their specialties and offer a wide range of delicious icing and cake flavors and fillings for every taste, delight your guests and fit your budget.

They also offer cake decorating workshops. Children from 6 years old, adults and families are appreciated. This event is available for future bookings for corporate group and / or team building events.


Wedding cakes, decoration class


Address: 10609 E Washington St Suite F, Indianapolis, IN 46229
Phone: (317) 626-2931
Website: www.princessconfections.com


“I couldn’t be happier with the cake and cupcakes Alana prepared for my wedding. You were a dream! Since we placed the order during the height of the Covid restrictions we couldn’t have a normal experience, but Alana was very responsive and provided us with a small box of samples so we could still make an informed decision. I highly recommend! “- Gavin p.

Brenda’s cakeBrenda's cake

Brenda’s cake Specialize in custom cakes and catering for all events. From the baby shower to her sweet 16 to your wedding, they can design the perfect cake and menu for your special occasion. The buttercreams and fondant icing made from scratch make your guests a delicious treat.

Planning a wedding can be nerve-wracking. One thing that you don’t have to worry about is the wedding cake. They offer a complete catering service for your next event. Pickup and drop-off ready for your personal or business event. From showers to graduation parties, they want to make your event even more special. Your employees will work with you every step of the way.


Weddings, all occasions, catering


Address: 6313 Rockville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46214
Phone: (317) 244-1241
Website: www.brendascakes.com


“Everything looks so good! They have creative ice cream flavors and fresh baked goods. They also have a cute back yard area shared with Russos. It’s a good date to go if you’re looking for a dessert spot in Indianapolis. “- Hannah T.


Shera Elliott graduated from New Mexico State University with a major in biology and a minor in biological foundations of behavior and health management. Shera grew up in Los Angeles but moved to college in Las Cruces. Shera has written for several major publications, including the Albuquerque Journal and NPR. Shera is a community reporter and also shares stories that are important to all Americans.