Below is a list of the best and premier seafood restaurants in Indianapolis. To help you find the best seafood restaurants near you in Indianapolis, we’ve created our own list based on this review score list.
Indianapolis’s best seafood restaurants:
The top rated seafood restaurants in Indianapolis are:
- The Juicy Seafood Restaurant offers a selection of delicious seafood prepared with the freshest meats and ingredients
- The Oceanaire Seafood Room offers sustainable and seasonal seafood with a chef-led menu
- Ocean Prime – an award-winning restaurant that offers a superb selection of seafood, steaks and cocktails
- Slapfish – makes its food available through dine-in, delivery and catering services
- Rick’s Cafe Boatyard – uses fresh, local seafood to create his masterpieces
The Juicy Seafood Restaurant
The Juicy Seafood Restaurant offers a selection of delicious seafood prepared with the freshest meats and ingredients. There are daily specials that their guests introduced as dishes. In addition, they serve fire dishes paired with Cajun or regular fries. This includes a basket of whiting fillet, a basket of fried oysters and a basket of chicken fillets. There is a choice of ranch, blue cheese, French, and Italian house salads as a side dish. In addition, their seafood dishes come with corn, potatoes, and boiled eggs. Theus include blue crabs, prawns. There are also spicy flavors of cajun, lemon pepper, garlic butter, and everything.
Address: 5899 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Telephone: (317) 296-3884
”Great taste for their seafood cooking! Fresh seafood. You have to try their prawns with your head. “- Sam Tang
The Oceanaire Seafood Room
The Oceanaire Seafood Room offers sustainable and seasonal seafood with a chef-led menu. It served delicious dishes to the community in 1998. They always include excellence in everything they do and serve. Chef’s specialties include lobster pot pie, fried chicken lobster, and Chesapeake Bay-style crab cakes. They also serve Hawaiian yellowfin tuna, king salmon, and wild Alaskan halibut that is coated with lemon butter. In addition, their prime steakhouse cuts are made with USDA-certified prime beef. There are also special cocktails and wines. They source their cocktails from top markets around the world.
Address: 30 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Telephone: (317) 955-2277
“Excellent food and better service. It’s above average and you should expect to pay for it. Great experience and good people. “- Dale Dillhoff
Ocean Prime is an award-winning restaurant that offers a first-class selection of seafood, steaks and cocktails. The restaurant has a stunning and classic setting. It also has a vibrant energy that allows guests to enjoy their food. They also serve lobster mac and cheese, filet mignon, and lobster biscuit. There are also selections such as teriyaki salmon, crab cakes, and Florida grouper. The sushi menu includes flavorful tuna, vegetable rolls, and prime roll. In addition, there are on-ice dishes such as Alaskan King Crab Legs, Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail, and Chilled Crab Meat Cocktail. Her delicious desserts are creme brulee, chocolate cake and sorbet.
Address: 8555 River Rd # 100, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Telephone: (317) 569-0975
My husband and I stayed here for our 11th anniversary. The service and food was great. We had a wonderful time. The courses were so far apart that we had time to rest and chat. We have no complaints. Even something as simple as a wedge salad exceeded expectations. They even packed a couple of desserts that we can enjoy at home for our anniversary. “- Jessica Armstrong
Slapfish provides its food through dine-in, delivery and catering services. They have a full bar with a full range of cocktails, wines and specialty mixes. Additionally, their popular products include traditional lobster bun, epic shrimp burrito, and grilled lobster cheese. There are also selections such as the ultimate fish taco, shrimp bun, and rollfish sandwich. Plus, there are gluten-free and vegetarian options for a street taco, poke bowls, simple grilled salads, and an epic burrito bowl. Their fish dishes a la carte are tilapia, lobster, salmon, sea bass and hoki.
Address: 345 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Telephone: (317) 686-9713
“One of the cheapest fish spots in Indy. The staff was lovely and very helpful. They are doing their best to deal with the pandemic. We stopped for the first time last night and it was phenomenal. The food was very tasty. The lobster taquitos and chowder fries were to die for. The lobster roll was some of the best we’ve ever had. I cannot recommend this hotel enough. “- Michelle Lauer
Rick’s Cafe Boatyard
Rick’s Cafe Boatyard uses fresh, locally sourced seafood to create its masterpieces. The restaurant is known for its tasty dishes and incomparable customer service. They also serve seafood dishes like tempura-fired leaping prawns, crab cakes, and red Alaskan king crab legs. There are also dishes such as seafood stir-fries, Atlantic salmon rolls, and South African lobster tail. In addition, their steaks and chops include filet mignon, crab fillet, and pork chop on the bone. There are also sandwiches like pulled or siders, pork tenderloin and salmon BLT.
Address: 4050 Dandy Trail, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: ((317) 290-9300
Really amazing experience! The food is phenomenal and well worth the higher price you will see! Definitely not small portions. We haven’t ordered anything out of the ordinary. You are under new management and it is evident that positive changes are being made! The staff was very attentive and competent! Great place for a special occasion or a date ”- Sarah M.
Jeanie Burford is a reporter for Kev’s Best. After graduating from UCLA, Amy did an internship at a local radio station and worked as a beat reporter and producer. Jeanie has also worked as a columnist for The Brookings Register. Amy covers business and community events for Kev’s Best.